Garnet And Black Attack: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Joel Pineiro pitches old enough to vote for Rutherford Hayes


FIVE POINTS: South Carolina 34, Arkansas 21

Fivepoints2008sat_medium
1. I want to be Ellis Johnson when I grow up. I'm so glad I was right about Ellis Johnson. Pay no attention to what I've written in the past: In my heart, I knew that Johnson would be the best choice for the job. Okay, so I was wrong. Never have I been happier, though, to be incorrect. The defense clamped down on Arkansas, holding one of the most explosive passing offenses in the SEC -- this is, admittedly, a rather dubious honor -- to 255 yards. Michael Smith? 25 yards on seven carries. On a day when the offense was -- um -- schizophrenic, the defense once again led the way to a win.

2. The rotating QBs. Yeah, let's not do that again. Steve Spurrier's not necessarily backing down, but I'm guessing we won't see quite as much swapping as we saw Saturday. It really didn't work; the combined passer rating for Chris Smelley and Stephen Garcia was 119.99, which is pretty mediocre for college football. I'm still not sure what the attraction is; from what I've seen (and granted, I didn't get to actually see Saturday's game), I still think Garcia's the better passer as well as the superior runner. But, at the very least, Spurrier needs to choose one quarterback -- for every possession, at least.

3. K-Mc's night. Kenny McKinley had his best game of the year, passing the century mark in yardage and Sterling Sharpe for a career.


vs Arkansas / 11.8.08Receiving
RecYardsAvgTD
Kenny McKinley 7 130 18.6 1


It's a shame that the best receiver in South Carolina history won't get an SEC championship. But an Outback Bowl sendoff wouldn't be so bad.

4. The running game survives. It wasn't pretty, but the Gamecocks managed 132 yards rushing, mostly through sheer force of will. They carried the ball 34 times, averaging 3.9 ypc. It's enough to make opponents account for the run, but the rushing game will have to be more intimidating if South Carolina ever wants to be better than third in the SEC East.

5. Rankings, bowls, etc. South Carolina moves to 23rd in the USA Today Poll, 24th in the AP and 25th in the BCS (for whatever good that does us). It might be a brief stay, depending on how respectable the likely loss against Florida is and what else happens next week. But it's still a good place to be to set up the Gamecocks if they can defeat Clemson and win a bowl game. The Outback Bowl still looks good, as long as South Carolina can reach 8-4.

GRADE: B-
Again, it's a win, and a pretty solid one at that. But this team is still missing something and needs to find it for its first nine-win (counting bowl game) season since 2001.

Poll
Grade the Gamecocks
A
3 votes
B
22 votes
C
4 votes
D
0 votes
F
0 votes

29 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 1 comment | Share on Facebook Digg!

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

As someone who did watch the game...

Smelley looked better than Garcia Saturday, at least while throwing the ball. They both threw some bad passes, but Garcia threw more. Not sure why; he usually seems more accurate than Smelley. My guess is that Chris responded better to the rotating system. Garcia’s mobility still stuck out as one difference between the two, though.

However he uses it, we haven’t seen the end of the rotating QBs system. Spurrier obviously doesn’t see much difference between the two and thinks he can outsmart opposing defenses by playing both. Whatever one thinks about the former, SOS is probably right about the latter, because we had open receivers all over the field Saturday. The only questions remaining is whether Garcia and Smelley can step up and do the job.

Go Cocks!

by Gamecock Man on Nov 10, 2008 10:25 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about South Carolina Gamecocks.
Start posting about the Gamecocks »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Stuff_043_1__small
Alshon Jeffery cleared to play.
Sir_big_spur_small
Public Service Announcement: Jersey Sale
Stuff_043_1__small
2010 Class to Date
Catscratchreader_m_small
What can the Carolina Panthers Expect from CB Captain Munnerlyn
Sir_big_spur_small
Mr. Irrelevant? Try Mr. Important.
Spurrierpissy_small
Mike Morgan's departure ... and why it stinks
Spurrierpissy_small
Garnet & Black Game observations
Stuff_043_1__small
How are you going to spend your summer: Open Thread

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Theirvote_small cocknfire

Uscgamecocks_small Gamecock Man

Official Partner of CBS Sports