Garnet And Black Attack: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Falcons and Chargers Recap: The Win Is The Thing Bar-right-arrows



spread the word

5 POINTS: South Carolina vs. Georgia

Fivepoints2008sat_medium
Having recovering from flinging pillows, remote controls and everything else within reach...

1. The season is not over. After the kind of deflating loss suffered last week against Vanderbilt, it would have been easy for the Gamecocks to mail it in. This team didn't do that. Take away a few dumb mental mistakes, and South Carolina might very well have beaten Georgia. That's not to take away from what the spelling-challenged Dawgs did; you only get credit in the win column if you emerge victorious. But there were plenty of opportunities to fold, and South Carolina didn't. They scrapped and fought and forced Georgia to play all-out until the end. That's the sign of a team rebounding from a tough loss and refusing to give in.

2. Awful refereeing. This had nothing to do with the outcome of the game. I don't think the officiating helped either team, though it might have hurt both of them. Sure, every crew is going to miss some calls and throw some bad or ticky-tacky flags. But this performance was abysmal. A delay-of-game flag against Georgia was picked up because of malfunctioning play clocks. Which is fine. The officials started keeping time on the field. Then, on the next South Carolina drive, they went back to working from the play clocks. And were promptly forced to pick up a delay-of-game flag against South Carolina. They waited until the end of timeouts to review plays, called two penalties "offsetting" fouls even though both were against South Carolina, and generally bumbled around like they were high-school refs called in because of a typhoid epidemic among SEC officials. If nothing else, they provided comic relief.

Refs_medium
'Should we just admit we don't know what we're doing?'

3. Containing Moreno. South Carolina by no means shut down Knowshon Moreno, but they certainly minimized the damage he did: 20 carries, 79 yards, one score. That was part of a defensive effort that, aside from some sloppy tackling and poor coverage that Matthew Stafford thankfully failed to notice, was generally solid. The Gamecocks' defense held the spelling-challenged Dawgs to 252 yards (and technically outgained them) despite being on the field for more than 35 minutes. Stafford completed 60 percent of his passes but averaged just 5.8 yards a pass. There were few big plays for Georgia. The problem was, there were even fewer for South Carolina.

4. Matthew Stafford Fan Club: Gary Danielson, President. I generally like the CBS crew, but I finally understand what those who despise Danielson are talking about. When he gets on a topic, it can be hard to get him off. When Matthew Stafford did well, it was a chance to talk about how great Matthew Stafford was. When Knowshon Moreno did well, it was a chance to talk about how great Matthew Stafford was. When the Georgia defense did well, it was a chance to talk about how great Matthew Stafford was. Listening to Danielson, it could be hard to remember that there were at least 21 other people on the field at any given time. And it came as a shock to realize that sometimes he was talking about a player that wasn't even on the field.

5. Moe Brown catches some. For once, a ball thrown to Moe Brown was not the kiss of death. In fairness, it hasn't always been Brown's fault that attempted passes to him ended in disaster. But, this week, Brown actually caught some passes -- and to good effect.


vs Georgia / 9.13.08Receiving
RecYardsAvgTD
Moe Brown 7 130 18.6 1

So is South Carolina finally figuring out who the playmakers are? Will Brown and Jared Cook (who had a less-than-stellar day) be able to compensate for the loss of Kenny McKinley and then be able to complement him when he returns? Can South Carolina continue to cobble together one good performance from this receiver and another solid showing from that receiver to keep its offense functioning? The questions won't be answered for sure until the Gamecocks start winning again.

GRADE: B-
I hate giving more than a C for a losing effort, but if you had told me before the game that this would be the result, I would have taken it. This was always going to be a tough game for South Carolina -- Georgia is peaking right now, and the Gamecocks are not. While a win would have been nice, this is about as good a loss as you could have.

Poll
Grade the Gamecocks.
A
5 votes
B
23 votes
C
14 votes
D
7 votes
F
9 votes

58 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 10 comments | Digg!

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Danielson is the president of the fan club of whichever quarterback has the lead. This week he was gushing about Stafford, and next week you can be sure he’ll be gushing about Tebow. It’s what he does.

by Year2 on Sep 14, 2008 1:39 AM EDT   0 recs

Fair enough

But it just seemed to get way out of line this week.

At least he wasn’t Brent Musberger, touting the Heism@n candidacy of a QB who didn’t even pass for 200 yards.

by cocknfire on Sep 14, 2008 4:36 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Fair asssessment

Believe me, we know that moral victories suck and that nothing makes up for losing.

But you sound like your hope is restored, and I think that’s valid based on the game today.

My pretty optimistic scenario is this: Vanderbilt is really pretty decent, so’s Carolina, we both go beat up on Tennessee and Kentucky (I’ll leave out Florida in the name of realism) and against the West, and we both finish with 7-9 wins.

I don’t think exactly that will happen, but it’s plausible, and that pleases me.

by PhilipVU94 on Sep 14, 2008 2:05 AM EDT   0 recs

I think...

… the victory was there for the Gamecocks’ taking, but there were too many mistakes.

I took away the following from this game:

1) Georgia is an eminently beatable team.
2) USCe has a pretty good defense.

That goal line fumble was an absolute killer. I feel your pain.

Orange and Blue Hue: The World through GATOR-colored Glasses -- http://www.orangeandbluehue.com

by Gatorpilot on Sep 14, 2008 9:31 AM EDT   0 recs

Yeah...

The goal line fumble ranks up there as one of those moments you’ll cry about for the rest of the season. You’re ready to explode with the joy of a game tying score and then bam! fumble it into the endzone.

But yeah, I liked what I saw yesterday. It’s depressing to constantly have to like what you see in a losing effort, but like I said, if our defense plays like that and our offense at least manages to be relatively mistake free, we’ll beat most teams. Maybe not the Gators, but does anyone seriously doubt that the team we saw yesterday can’t beat the Vols or Clemson?

Go Cocks!

by Gamecock Man on Sep 14, 2008 10:40 AM EDT   0 recs

And by the way...

You’re right; Danielson was horrible yesterday. He’s bad sometimes, but he ruined the play by play. He had done no research on the Gamecocks and didn’t really know what he was talking about other than when talking about Stafford. We were in the middle of a fourth quarter dog fight and all he could talk about was Stafford and UGA’s title chances, even though they very well could have died yesterday.

I can see why fans of other conferences hate him. He’s an SEC company guy, the same way Herbstreit is a Big 10 guy. Only maybe Danielson is worse.

Go Cocks!

by Gamecock Man on Sep 14, 2008 10:43 AM EDT   0 recs

Danielson

I generally like his analysis, but he does tend to gush. He waxed on and on about Tebow in the 2007 UF-FSU game — hard for me to disagree as a Gator fan, but I can see how that would be irritating to fans of the other team.

His complimentary commentary about Stafford seemed a little excessive in my view. Stafford made a couple of nice throws, sure. He was also unable to put up more than two touchdowns against a defense that allowed more yards and points to Vanderbilt (no disrespect intended of course.) So gushing about Stafford and his fourteen points seemed somewhat misplaced to me. It would have looked really foolish if South Carolina found a way to win the game.

Imagine if that goal line fumble hadn’t occured and the Cocks got the ball back late in the 4th — all they’d have needed was a FG to win.

Orange and Blue Hue: The World through GATOR-colored Glasses -- http://www.orangeandbluehue.com

by Gatorpilot on Sep 14, 2008 11:21 AM EDT   0 recs

Pilot...

The reason you probably think that Danielson is OK is b/c Florida is typically on the good side of his gushing. Not that Tebow or Stafford don’t deserve it, but it would be nice to see that he has something to say about non-Heisman contenders. Like I said, I think the worst part was that it continued well into the fourth quarter when it looked like we might have a chance to pull it out. You’re right; if we had won, he would’ve looked really silly having gone the entire game gushing about a QB that couldn’t get his offense going any better than Vandy’s.

Go Cocks!

by Gamecock Man on Sep 14, 2008 11:52 AM EDT   0 recs

Understood

Right, and I can see your point there, but aside from gushing (whether it’s net positive or negative for any team) I think he’s very astute with his in-game analysis. He really seems to have his head in the game and has a knack for explaining some of the tit-for-tat coaching moves made on the field in a way that is informative and interesting. For that reason, I like him.

Orange and Blue Hue: The World through GATOR-colored Glasses -- http://www.orangeandbluehue.com

by Gatorpilot on Sep 14, 2008 2:40 PM EDT   0 recs

Fair enough...

I will admit that his analysis is pretty good when he’s giving it to us. And he wasn’t all Georgia. He did have some interesting things to say about why we were able to move the ball better in the fourth quarter.

I just can’t help thinking he’s a total SEC company guy for the endless hype he gives to the conference’s premier teams and players. Like you, I’m an SEC fan, so I often agree with him, but I can see why another conference’s fans might see him like we see Kirk Herbstreit and the Big 10.

Go Cocks!

by Gamecock Man on Sep 14, 2008 2:58 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about South Carolina Gamecocks.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Images_small
Where oh where is the top offensive recruiting?
Small
Fla and So Cal : SEC and Pac 10
Mac_small
A Quick Game of "What if?"
Small
Ol' Ball Coach Has Gamecocks Moving Forward
Small
The Proudest Father Alive - Part 2
Small
The Proudest Father Alive - Part 1
Small
FAIL
Small
Can Clemson say "One and Done"?
Small
McDanniel
Millers_crossing
Mark Dantonio

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Gabalogo2_small cocknfire

Uscgamecocks_small Gamecock Man

ad

Site Meter