South Carolina Football All-Decade Team: Runningback
This post continues a series picking an All-Decade Team. Over the summer, we'll be honoring the best players Carolina has had at each position over the past ten years. We'll also give shout-outs to some of the other memorable players we've had. In our last two installments of this series, I picked Ryan Succop as our top placekicker and Spencer Lanning as our punter.
Today, we're talking about runningbacks. Runningback has been a funny position for Carolina. We've gone through quite a few runningbacks over the last few years. In general, there's been a lot of promise but not always a lot of genuine success for our running game. There are some impressive talents on this list, but few of them have genuinely challenged for All-SEC status.
Since 2001, South Carolina's principal runningbacks have been as follows:
2001: Andrew Pinnock and Derek Watson
2002: Andrew Pinnock, Daccus Turman, and Kenny Irons
2003: Daccus Turman, Demetris Summers, and Cory Boyd
2004: Demetris Summers, Cory Boyd, Gonzie Gray, Daccus Turman
2005: Mike Davis, Daccus Turman, Bobby Wallace
2006: Cory Boyd, Mike Davis
2007: Cory Body, Mike Davis
2008: Mike Davis, Eric Baker, Brian Maddox
2009: Kenny Miles, Brian Maddox
2010: Marcus Lattimore, Brian Maddox, Kenny Miles
To me, there are two guys who stand out here: Boyd and Lattimore. There are also some other guys who did some impressive things. Watson ran for just over 1000 yards in 2000, the year before our range begins. Summers had his moments. Davis had a good freshman season. But Boyd and Lattimore really stand out above the rest of the pack.
Picking between the two is tough. On the one hand, Lattimore has the best single season. He ran for well over 1000 yards last year, was first-team All-SEC, and took home many Freshman Player of the Year Awards. On the other hand, Lattimore only has one year to his credit, whereas Boyd proved himself over the course of several years, particularly in 2006 and 2007. I've also always thought that Boyd would have had a much better senior season if Carolina had fielded an effective offensive line that year. Finally, Boyd has this beautiful play to his credit:
Eric Berry gets juked out of his shoes by Cory Boyd (via Delta900)
All of that said, I think the pick has to go to Lattimore. Not only has Lattimore brought home more hardware; you also have to give him credit for being the player who brought us over the hump. It certainly wasn't Boyd's fault that we struggled during some of his years. However, he wasn't able to be as much of a difference-maker as Lattimore, either.
Since this is a tough one, I'd like to open it up to the forum: Who would you pick?
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
isnt it customary
to list two RB on awards teams? I could see limiting it to one if you wanted to award a FB position, but then Pinnock often lined up at fullback and it would be a battle between him, DiMarco and …. really that’s about it.
Here, Corey deserves the nod for his body of work. But Marcus Lattimore is a once in a generation type talent, who clearly was the difference-maker on the best squad in your specified time period …. so (if it were left up to me), we’d give an honorary mention to our best FB (whoever that may be!) …..
PK Ryan Succop
P Spencer Lanning
RB Cory Boyd
RB Marcus Lattimore
It’s a waffle, but a nice waffle! FB is mostly a part-time position for Carolina Plus – if the Fates had given us Corey Boyd and Marcus Lattimore at the same time, I bet you the HBC would’ve found a way to play ’em both on the field together.
I always liked Pinnock and Davis – tough and hard-working – and wish they could have had more success (though Pinnock did have six seasons in the NFL after being a 7th round draft pick).
The crash-and-burn of Demetris Summers still hurts after all this time – talk about coulda, woulda, shoulda.
They wore garnet helmets.
That seems fair. We can have two. You're right that that's what the All-American Teams ,etc., do.
Garnet and Black Attack: A Blog By and For Gamecocks Fans.
by Gamecock Man on May 13, 2011 12:28 PM EDT up reply actions
Assuming you have two RB (which subsumes/includes the FB position)
that leaves one QB, three WR/TE and five OL.
Out of curiosity, are you going to do WR and OL as a group or break them out? I’m pretty sure there will be a consensus of at least WR1 and WR2, but OL is going to take a lot of research I think and will be very interesting.
They wore garnet helmets.
Who would you rather have next year?
Look at our performance in 2010 with him and without Lattimore. Look at his role in the big games we won. I appreciate Boyd’s long service to Carolina, but to proclaim him the best back who played for USC between 2001-2010 is to ignore reality.
I take Lattimore of course
every time. But … awards like All-Decade Teams, to my mind, are not purely based on who is the best talent, or who had the best single year in the specified time period, but who had the biggest impact over the time frame.
Plus, if Marcus continues to play and improve like we think he will (scary to think he will improve since he’s already amazingly talented) then he will likely be on GABA’s 2011-2020 All Decade team!
They wore garnet helmets.
Agreed.
And your question ssladler, really sums it up. I would take Lattimore. I still remember being ok with losing Summers as long as we had Boyd. What I liked about Cory was also his ability to catch passes. He made some amazing one-hand catches.
But I can’t watch highlights from UGA, UK, UF and Bama last year and not pick Lattimore.
- FOW
by skandrewj62j on May 13, 2011 9:44 AM EDT up reply actions
Your question, ssladler, really sums up why I picked Lattimore.
That said, I do think tryptic has a point about the impact Cory Boyd had on this team over the course of his career. He’s definitely a tried and true Gamecock.
Garnet and Black Attack: A Blog By and For Gamecocks Fans.
by Gamecock Man on May 13, 2011 12:28 PM EDT up reply actions
I agree with ssadler as well. Who's the best? Marcus Lattimore. He'll play in two decades, and he'll be the best in both of them.
by Skulls and Spurs on May 15, 2011 10:47 PM EDT up reply actions
From a sheer talent perspective, Boyd is fourth on the list.
No disrespect to his contributions, which were significant, but if I’m picking sides on the playground I’m taking Watson and Summers over him without question.
by Skulls and Spurs on May 15, 2011 10:51 PM EDT up reply actions
I think boyd should get it for this past decade
Seeing as how his whole career was played during it and not just one year. Lattimore will have his name all over next decades, and it isnt like Boyd doesnt deserve it.

by 













