Garnet And Black Attack: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Click Here :: Absolut NFL Weekend Buffet, Week 15: It's Time To Pray

On Ron Morris, Steve Spurrier, and Stephen Garcia

This just in: Ron Morris has written a controversial article about Steve Spurrier and the Gamecocks. For those of you in shock, believe it: follow this link, and you'll actually see Morris criticizing Spurrier's coaching. The jist of the article? Spurrier is being too hard on Stephen Garcia. He's hurting poor Stephen's confidence by constantly criticizing him.

In all seriousness, I suppose we shouldn't be surprised. Morris buys his lunch with articles designed to pique the USC and Clemson fanbases, and his choice to write a provocative article about a topic that is divisive among USC people should be taken with a grain of salt. Still, since this does seem to be an issue that has divided USC fans more or less since late in 2008, I feel like I should say where I stand. And where I stand on this one is with Spurrier.

As Spurrier has stated time and time again, confidence has never been the issue for Garcia. Motivation is. And anyone who payed attention and noticed that Garcia showed up to spring training looking like he had been living on Maurice's BBQ and Budweiser since the Papa John's Bowl should realize that Garcia hasn't been motivated enough over the past few months. The fact that Garcia still has some of the same issues--unorthodox throwing motion, underthrowing deep balls, happy feet in the pocket--shows the same thing. These are the issues that are holding Garcia back, not his confidence. And what they suggest are that he needs to work harder, which is exactly what Spurrier is trying to make him do. Even Morris admits that Spurrier is doing well in that regard, writing

IF THE POINT of Steve Spurrier browbeating Stephen Garcia throughout the spring was to ensure an offseason of diligent workouts by the junior quarterback, well, let's call it Mission Accomplished. Garcia is likely to be the hardest worker on the USC team this summer.

Morris, though, suggests that maybe more practice isn't what Garcia needs, but rather more confidence.

 

What Morris wrongly wants to dismiss, though, is that Spurrier is precisely right about what will produce more confidence in Garcia. As Spurrier, cited by Morris, says,

Confidence comes from executing your assignment, comes from knowing your assignments. Confidence comes from doing it over and over again in practice. Confidence comes from being fundamentally sound and having success. Success breeds confidence.

He's right. You know who the most confident quarterbacks in college football are? They're guys like Tim Tebow, Colt McCoy, and Sam Bradford, all of whom work their butts off to become better players and who build their confidence by executing in big games. No, their coaches don't berate them like Spurrier does to Garcia, but their coaches don't need to. Why would Spurrier treat Garcia like he's Tebow? Garcia doesn't play like Tebow. It's worth noting here that Spurrier has never been reticent to praise Garcia after a strong performance. He even praised him after losing to UGA last year, and you know Spurrier wasn't in a good mood after losing to his lifelong archrival.

 

A lot of Gamecocks fans love Garcia, and I'll admit that I do sometimes, too. Garcia proved himself to be a competitor last year, improving his overall play and oftentimes laying his body on the line to make big plays. However, his performance this spring has been lacking, and Spurrier is right to push him hard so he works over the summer to take his game to the next level. And I believe that's exactly what he'll do. He might not, though, without a little nudge from Spurrier. What has he done over the course of his career here to make you believe he would?

Poll
Is Spurrier being too hard on Garcia?
Yes.
13 votes
No.
50 votes
Maybe. I'm not sure.
2 votes

65 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

He only plays good against Kentucky

(sigh)

Then it comes to be that the soothing light at the end of your tunnel
is just a freight train coming your way.

by btcoop71 on Apr 15, 2025 12:47 PM EDT reply actions  

He does seem to be at his best against the 'Cats.

Although he’s had other good games, too.

Garnet and Black Attack: A Blog by and for Gamecocks Fans.

by Gamecock Man on Apr 15, 2025 1:20 PM EDT up reply actions  

Eh, I'm that lone undecided vote.

You make a compelling case, Gamecock Man. It just seems like Spurrier is always down on Garcia. You’ve got to sprinkle in some praise there every now and then, otherwise Garcia won’t see the light at the end of the tunnel. If Garcia can do no right, at some point he’ll give up and ask “Well if nothing is good enough, then why am I trying?” Who do know that that might have happened to? Smelley, Beecher, McCollum, and Hillary come to mind. Use the carrot and the stick. More stick if you like.

I also think you’re being a bit generous by saying Spurrier has never been reticent to praise Garcia. His praise of any quarterback has never surpassed “Yeah, he had a couple good ones here and there. But anyway…” His criticism is much more scathing.

If I ever find myself on the same side of an issue as Ron Morris I’ll need to re-evaluate my priorities. Hence, I am abstaining from judgment for the moment.

Dum spiro spero - "While I breathe, I hope"
State motto of South Carolina

by The Feathered Warrior on Apr 15, 2025 9:13 PM EDT reply actions  

Has Spurrier been reticent to praise Garcia?

I’m not looking this up, but this is what I remember about what Spurrier has had to say about Garcia after good performances.

Post-Kentucky 2008. Said Garcia played great, won the game for us. Said he had to start Garcia against LSU because Garcia gave us hope.
Post-UGA 2009. Said Garcia played super. Did everything he needed to do to win us the game. Defense and special teams cost us.
Post-Kentucky 2009. Said Garcia played great. Took some unnecessary sacks, but also made some key plays. Laid his body on the line for the clinching first down.
Post-Clemson 2009. Said he played well. Turning into a leader.
Throughout the 2009 season. Said he’s playing smarter. May not be making all the plays he needs to, but not turning the ball over is progress.
Early spring practice 2010. Said he’s acting like more of a leader.

I can remember other moments of praise, although I’ll grant that at times they’ve been few and far between, and the criticism has been frequent at times. But to me, that’s just an indication of where we are right now at the QB position. The kicker for me is this: if Spurrier had, until now, stopped criticizing Garcia, what would that mean? It would mean that Spurrier would have been happy with mediocrity, because that’s what Garcia has usually been. Sure, he was second in the league in yards. He also led the league in attempts and was very low in efficiency. Garcia hasn’t been a great quarterback. It hasn’t all been his fault, of course, but those are the facts. And I don’t want Spurrier to be happy with mediocre QB play.

I think it’s also worth noting that the reason Spurrier is probably so hard on Garcia is that he believes Garcia can be good. Spurrier was never so hard on Smelley or even Mitchell. I also really think that Garcia will end up being one of the best QBs who has ever played for us. Spurrier knows what he’s doing. 2009 Garcia was not 2005 Blake Mitchell. Garcia will end up winning a lot more games.

Garnet and Black Attack: A Blog by and for Gamecocks Fans.

by Gamecock Man on Apr 15, 2025 10:06 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about South Carolina Gamecocks.

The Absolut Bloody Hour CountdownClick Here

::

Enjoy with ABSOLUT Responsibility®

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

34968_677590062134_21311701_39025755_2244243_n_small
Dear Free-marketeers: How much of your company's corporate profits do you see?
Uscgamecocks_small
Bowl Open Thread
6061-1_1__small
SB Nation College Bowl Pick Em' December 18th Recap
6061-1_1__small
SB Nation College Bowl Pick Em'
Avatar_67471_small
What's More Important?
34968_677590062134_21311701_39025755_2244243_n_small
Thougts from ATl
Dscn2426_small
Awful Announcing
Here's to a good game ...
Small
Beat Auburn.
Spur_avatar_rivals_small
Of Clemson and culture shifts

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

NCAA Football -- FanHouse

  • Tulsa Lives Up to Hurricane Nickname, Blows Out Hawaii 62-35 in Hawaii Bowl
  • Hawaii vs Tulsa: Sheraton Hawaii Bowl
  • Five-Step Drop: So Long, JoePa?
  • Brady Hoke's Coaching Profile on Rise as San Diego State Thumps Navy

SBNation.com Recent Stories

+1 updates

Hawaii Bowl, Hawaii Vs. Tulsa: Golden Hurricane Wrecks Warriors, 62-35

Photo +12 updates

Poinsettia Bowl, Navy Vs. San Diego State: Aztecs Emerge Victorious In Soggy San Diego, 35-14

COLUMBUS OH - NOVEMBER 13:  Quarterback Terrelle Pryor #2 of the Ohio State Buckeyes looks for running room as Stephon Morris #12 of the Penn State Nittany Lions defends at Ohio Stadium on November 13 2010 in Columbus Ohio.  (Photo by Jamie Sabau/Getty Images) +6 updates

Terrelle Pryor Among Five Ohio State Football Players Suspended For First Five Games Next Season

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Gabalogo2_small cocknfire

Uscgamecocks_small Gamecock Man

Authors

Sir_big_spur_small The Feathered Warrior

Images_small GwinnettGamecock

Forevertothee_small Skulls and Spurs